Head-to-Head: Scotty DepthPower vs. Scotty High Performance (HP) Electric Downriggers

When it comes to deep-water trolling, Scotty has established itself as a benchmark for reliability and performance. Two of their most popular electric downrigger lines, the DepthPower and the High Performance (HP), are staples on fishing boats across British Columbia and beyond. While both are built to last and will effectively get your lure to the strike zone, they are designed with different anglers and applications in mind. This detailed comparison breaks down the key differences to help you choose the right tool for the job.

At a Glance: The Core Difference

The primary distinction between the Scotty DepthPower and the High Performance series lies in speed and power. The HP models are engineered for the serious angler and professional guide who demand the fastest retrieval speeds and the ability to handle heavier weights, minimizing downtime between catches and optimizing efficiency on the water. The DepthPower series, while still robust and powerful, is the workhorse of the recreational fleet, offering exceptional reliability and performance at a more accessible price point.

Feature by Feature Breakdown

Feature	Scotty DepthPower Series (e.g., 1106, 1116 Propack)	Scotty High Performance (HP) Series (e.g., 2106, 2116 Propack)
Retrieval Speed	Standard: e.g., 235 ft/min with a 7lb ball	Fastest: e.g., 295 ft/min with a 15lb ball
Lifting Capacity	Strong: Rated for up to 15lb downrigger balls	Superior: Rated for up to 20lb downrigger balls
Line Counter	Mechanical, resettable counter	Illuminated, sealed, and silent digital LCD counter
Amperage Draw	Lower (e.g., ~5-8 amps under load)	Higher (e.g., ~13-19.5 amps under load)
Motor & Drive	Custom-designed marine motor with Kevlar belt drive	High-torque, custom-designed marine motor with Kevlar belt drive
Included Rod Holder	Typically a single Rodmaster II	Can include single or dual Rocket Launcher/Rodmaster II holders
Target Angler	Serious recreational anglers	Tournament anglers and professional guides

Deep Dive into the Details

Retrieval Speed: The Need for Speed

The most significant advantage of the High Performance (HP) series is its retrieval speed. With the ability to pull a 15-pound weight up at nearly 300 feet per minute, the HP models are the fastest on the market. This speed is a critical factor for professional guides or tournament anglers who need to clear lines quickly to reposition for another pass or to avoid tangles when a fish is on. For anglers fishing in deep water or in areas with strong currents where quick resets are paramount, the HP series is unmatched.

The DepthPower series is no slouch, with retrieval speeds that were once the industry standard. It can retrieve a 7-pound weight at 235 feet per minute, which is more than adequate for the majority of recreational fishing scenarios. For the weekend angler or those who are not as concerned with shaving seconds off their retrieval time, the DepthPower offers a perfect blend of performance and value.

Lifting Power and Heavy-Duty Use

Directly related to their speed, the HP downriggers boast a more powerful motor, giving them the ability to comfortably lift downrigger balls up to 20 pounds. This is particularly advantageous when fishing in strong tides or at extreme depths where heavier weights are necessary to maintain the desired depth and reduce blowback (the angle of the downrigger line in the water).

The DepthPower series is rated for weights up to 15 pounds, which covers the vast majority of trolling applications, especially in the lakes and coastal waters of British Columbia. For most anglers targeting salmon, halibut, or lake trout, the lifting capacity of the DepthPower is more than sufficient.

The Counter: Analog Workhorse vs. Digital Precision

A key visual and functional difference is the line counter. The DepthPower models are equipped with a time-tested, reliable mechanical counter. It’s easy to read, simple to operate, and has a proven track record of durability.

The High Performance series features a modern, illuminated, and sealed digital LCD counter. This provides a clear, precise reading of your depth, which is especially useful in low-light conditions. While some users have noted a preference for the simplicity and perceived long-term reliability of the mechanical counter, the digital display on the HP models offers a level of precision and ease of use that many modern anglers appreciate.

Power Consumption

The increased power and speed of the HP downriggers come at the cost of a higher amperage draw. Anglers with smaller boats or less robust electrical systems should consider this. It’s crucial to ensure your boat’s battery and wiring can handle the increased load, especially when running multiple HP downriggers.

The DepthPower series is more energy-efficient, drawing significantly less power from your battery. This can be a deciding factor for anglers on multi-day trips or those with simpler 12-volt systems.

Which Model is Right for You?

Choose the Scotty DepthPower if:

You are a serious recreational angler who values reliability and performance.
You typically use downrigger balls of 15 pounds or less.
You prefer the simplicity and proven durability of a mechanical counter.
Your boat has a standard electrical system, and energy efficiency is a consideration.
You are looking for the best overall value in a high-quality electric downrigger.

Choose the Scotty High Performance (HP) if:

You are a professional guide, a tournament angler, or an angler who demands the absolute best in speed and efficiency.
You frequently fish in deep water or strong currents that require heavier (up to 20lb) weights.
You need to retrieve your gear as quickly as possible to maximize your fishing time.
You prefer the precision and low-light visibility of an illuminated digital counter.
Your boat’s electrical system can comfortably support the higher amperage draw.

Ultimately, the choice between the Scotty DepthPower and the High Performance series comes down to your specific needs and budget. Both are backed by Scotty’s legendary lifetime warranty and are built to withstand the demanding conditions of the Pacific Northwest and beyond. The DepthPower is the dependable workhorse, while the High Performance is the high-octane choice for those who need to push their gear to the absolute limit.